Get your American Idol Songs Here

LIVE VERDICT - 3 OCT 2005

Submitted by djwright on Mon, 2005-10-03 19:30

Voting Lines Are CLOSED

Guess what?

I'm back... Long story as to my whereabouts over the last 2 weeks, but I'll get to that later, but for now get ready for the verdict for the top 9...

Last night the idols were asked to sing their favorite songs, and, as is normally the case we, as a nation found out that not one of the hopefuls have one iota of musical taste whatsoever… From Lee singing a phenomenal song without any passion to Dan Spillaine singing 1927 the entire night was one horrific exposé into why these people should never ever be voted in as idol. Imagine a CD put together by an individual with music taste like these guys, how positively awful would it be?

The words “as painful as dripping acid onto a hemorrhoid

I'm prediciting what my mark

I'm prediciting what my mark will be on Sunday night... BIG BAND...

Anne: 6/10... i think she'll do a good performance... but BIG BAND isn't her night.

Daniel S: 4/10... i think will do a bad performance... wouldn't impress Mark.

Emily: 5 and a half... i think she'll do an O.K. job... BIG BAND not her type.

Kate: 7/10... i think she'll impress Mark and Marcia, NOT Kyle... She blends with the ngiht.

James: 6 and a half... i think would stuff up, but will impress me... not his type of genre, but some how fit's in it.

Milly: 7 and a half... i think BIG BAND is Milly's type, she'll do well... but from her last performance wont have enough supporters to get her through next round.

Dan E: 6 and a half/10... i think not his style... Will recieve a good comment from Marcia, will recieve an .O.K. performance from Kyle, and i believe Mark will give him a hard time.

Lee: 5 and a half/10... Lee will do an O.K. job... he wont do really good, but will get through next round from supporters.

BOTTOM 3...      (* = Will leave)

Daniel S

Milly*

James

I reckon Milly will nail

I reckon Milly will nail this one...If teeny girls still stick with Lee & Dan E, even if they sing crap, I'm prediting -especially if Dan S and Milly pull it off- there will be some surprises in the bottom three...

soooo unfair...

There is only two or three

There is only two or three contestants, that have delivered a consistant performance, a couple that have been just ok, some that are going backwards, and two that are terrible.

If Milly or Dan S, James do not lift there act, these three should go one after the other, they are no where near as good as Kate, Anne, or Emily. There is such a distance in the quality of singers this year. I have no idea who is going to win this at guess. Probably the most popular personality, not singer.

I find it hilarious that

I find it hilarious that there is this one person calling Roxane's departure the biggest shcok ever. Look around you, no one else is too suprised and almost no one is calling this a "scandel" Go back to the Roxane site, I for one have heard enough.

right on french maid...

right on french maid...:)

NO ONE VOTE FOR EMILY...SHE

NO ONE VOTE FOR EMILY...

SHE DOES NOT DESERVE TO STAY...

WE ALL KNOW SHE CAN'T SING BIG BAND...

AND IT'S THIS WEEK...

EMILY OVER ROXANE...  NO WAY... ROXANE IS 10 TIMES BETTER...

EMILY IS "EGGOGO TO THE MAX TIMES 10 PLUS 1...

ROXANE 4 LIFE

FROM HER NO.1 FAN,

ROXANELOVER

Roxane clearly did not

Roxane clearly did not deserve to go home.

She was a great singer, with a different style.

Roxane has fighted a long hard trip making it to the TOP 13.

Whether she will go out and not produce any singles, she will always be one of the best idol's we have had on this show.

In the real world, James,

In the real world, James, Milly and Dan S should be going over the next few weeks.

But...in the Idol voting world, no-one is safe.

That's scarey...

I'm starting to lose faith...

I think that this whole

I think that this whole competition has gone down the drain. I don't know what happened, every week everyone gets heaps worse. Kate was the only one who didnt drop in my stakes.

I then ask myself, we thought last year was crap! Chanel, god I miss your origionalitiy and song choice, this lot is shat.

I would also like to say that the "official" Website is also crap and consumed by adds and the only reason anyone goes there is for videos and tickets. Does anyone else know where I can get full videos or audios? They had some wierd site last year.

Good work on the Dan/Casey comment. I love it how Mark refuses to admit that Casey had screwed up.

"we, as a nation found out

"we, as a nation found out that not one of the hopefuls have one iota of musical taste whatsoever"

on the mark!  this fiasco has made me wish someone like Courtney was in the contest this year. 

"Dan England is starting to look like a male version of Casey Donovan"

also on the mark! 

welcome back by the way.  it's been an absolutely crazy week.

Mark Holden's comments have

Mark Holden's comments have been pretty accurate for most. Which only reflects on the judges for being shocking picks of talent.
The only one that actually had any musical ability in the finals was Chris Luta, except he had a girls voice. But at least he knew how to choose songs. This utterly shocking group can't even get the basics of song selection right.Let alone just being hacks.
Ok Anne and Emily have potential, but the others are so awful it makes me want to put nails in my head

something different? if

something different? if these judges want to prove just how good a judge of talent they really are (and their choices so far are not showing it) why not have a "Judges Choice" show?  Maybe the judges plus john and erana could sit down and select two or three songs for each contestant that they believe would best suit their voices and personalities and see what happens?

Judges choice is an

Judges choice is an interesting idea.  Remember X factor where the songs were mostly judges choice?  It was fairly disastrous as I recall. 

I think the real problem here is most of these poor kids are out of their depth or are convinced that they are supremely talented because they can stand there and scream. 

Kate is the only one who can confidently deliver a song without attempting/failing to be a north american R&B diva.  Go Kate!

The reality is the judges

The reality is the judges have no idea for talent and the people they put up on stage are delivering exactly what they are capable of - nothing.

Go back and listen to Anthony's "Bridge Over Troubled Water" if you want to hear what the standard for this show should be about. Not the rubbish this lot is dealing up each week. They're as talentless as the X factor group.

At least in American Idol they pick singers first and then try to develop their performance. Not rubbish like Lee who just throats out pub standard rubbish and they say he is a "performer".

As for Roxane, her chipmunk album will no longer be made. What was she thinking trying to sing a tough Christina Aguilera while sucking down helium.

ROXANE OBVIOUSLY DID NOT

ROXANE OBVIOUSLY DID NOT DESERVE TO GO.

SHE IMPRESSED ALL JUDGES.

AND MILLIONS OF AUSTRALIANS.

ROXANE YOU DO YOUR THING... AND BECOME THE HIGHEST SELLING SINGLE AND ALBUM... IN HISTORY... LOVE YOU BABY...

YOU ROCK!

ROXANE WAS THE BEST

ROXANE WAS THE BEST EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! STUPID MILLY SHOULD HAVE GONE

ROXANE AND KATE WERE THE ONLY GOOD ONES IN CONTESTANTS CHOICE

i can go put on the chipmunk

i can go put on the chipmunk album if i want to listen to Roxane sing - shocking!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Home