Get your American Idol Songs Here

Live Verdict - 17 October

Submitted by djwright on Mon, 2005-10-17 19:31

VOTING NOW CLOSED

Yes, that's right, after last night's awful performances we will see one of the top 7 leave the competition leaving us with 6...

Who will go?

Who will stay?

We'll find out soon!!!

Idolblog Polls:
After the performances the bottom 3 were:
Daniel Spillane 4%
James Kannis 7%
Kate DeAraugo 8%

While before the performances the bottom 3 were:
Daniel Spillane 4%
James Kannis 7%
Dan England 9%

So, it’s my guess that we’ll be saying goodbye to Daniel tonight, although I’d really like to see James out this week…

The Group Song:
Tonight the idols sang Rick Astley’s “Never Gonna Give You Up.

James was a nice guy.  If

James was a nice guy.  If this was Big Brother, he would have won the thing.  And I think that he got this far purely on his personality.... people liked him.  But his singing was never ever that great.  If he had a bit less charm, he would have gone weeks ago.

I thought the group

I thought the group performance was one of the best...out of a bad bunch that is...

my god, the other

my god, the other performances must have been unbearable because that effort was rank. I think these guys are burn't out and frankly not good enough to make a go of it in a demanding industry. Only Emily maybe because she has enough natural talent to pull her through hard times (if she ever stops crying over everything)

I found all rather a bit

I found all rather a bit emotional tonight...the girls crying...the song...Kannis actually getting in 'the pocket' for a change...it was his best darn performance...

I was just so sure it was going to be Kate in the bottom three...but OMG...she has a fan base happening...or it was my last minute votes that got her across the line...whatever, it worked...

Just goes to show...no-one is safe...no-one is safe...yeah, now Emily's votes are going to shoot through the roof...

But over all, order has been restored...

i know!!! he WAS so friggin

i know!!! he WAS so friggin good 2night!..pisses me off how he never tried that MUCH earlier..:'( still kinda recovering that he got out soo early. Surprisinly no tears have fallen yet..even tho i was cryin when he was in the bottom 3 every past few weeks...guess it's still not sunken in..-sigh-

do u all think he'l have an album out? cos 1st idol group..(no. 7) rebekah had an album out..2nd idol group..(no. 7) Rikki had an album out..and James is like already famous in the girl teen mags...so???..wat do u guys think? *fingers crossed*

 ~*luving James 4eva*~

hey...i take my hat off to

hey...i take my hat off to james....i think he went far....further than i expected to tell you the truth....

i rekon he will make it big somewhere in tv as well as cd's...but tv will be his strong point...hes got a great personality....:)

go emily, anne, kate...and spillane

really? thanks!yea

really? thanks!

yea hopefully...tv..and movies but i'd rather him release an album..cos he's got SUCH a gorgeous voice...

~*luving James 4eva*~

I do agree, he's got a good

I do agree, he's got a good chance of doing well on TV... on Neighbours or hosting some kids quiz show where they drop slime on you or something.

But an Album?  eh.

yer hes got talent....he

yer hes got talent....he wouldnt of gotten this far....

but i tell you...im listenin to annes song at the moment...

shes magical...touchdown worthy.....

mark holden...COME ON!!.....lol sorry to change the subject...i got carried away...so..i want u 2 give me ur favourite to least favourite from 1 - 6....

lol dw..i like Anne ok..fav

lol dw..i like Anne :)

ok..fav -> least

Lee, Kate, Daniel---> even tho he was meant 2 get our 2night..*grr*, Anne, Dan, Emily...

~*luving James 4eva*~

YES... FINALLY SOME ONE WHO

YES... FINALLY SOME ONE WHO HATES EMILY AS MUCH AS I DO...

I CAN'T STAND HER VOICE... IT'S SHOCKING...

so ur like roxanelover...u

so ur like roxanelover...u hate emily....oh well loll.....i love emily...her voice is so...so....i cant think of a word....but its a good word...lol....

awww..lol, i dont HATE

awww..lol, i dont HATE her..just ..dislike her lol..

she seems really nice..just that i really dont like her style...u know who i hate from Idol?..Natalie..*shivers*

~*luving James 4eva*~

you really like Lee and

you really like Lee and James??

Don't any of you guys actually enjoy good singing?

Hah! it's called living in

Hah! it's called living in the 21st century !

I thought may have been a

I thought may have been a shock tonight, but I was thinking of Kate or Anne not Emily, probably get hate posts for this, but I was hopeing Lee was in the bottom three.

Please Australia, wake up

Please Australia, wake up and kick off Lee. What is wrong with you people? Even Lee knows he's no good. I can see Lee any time I want to go to a pub and get my ears blasted off by distorted rubbish.

James should never have been in the top 30 let alone making it to final 12. Well I say that about all of them except for Emily (only one who can sing)

I agree James may not have

I agree James may not have been the best singer but think of being in their shoes for once? Lee does have a voice and its recordable. If Emily won I'd be happy but Lee doesn't deserve this crap. I'm glad that James went cos he has a lot of problems to fix but for goodness sake leave lee alone. He is a good singer..

Ah come on, you know Lee

Ah come on, you know Lee can't sing. He just has drums and guitar drowning out his own noise with more noise. He is getting by simply on jumping around and have coloured hair. James can't sing, but he sings better than Lee. That's how bad Lee is! God, he's as bad as that Jeremy guy was. Maybe worse. Holden said that he got a tough time about giving a touchdown to Lee by music people. Surprise, surprise. People that actually know anything about music think Lee is a joke.

I hope Lee does win, because the Celine Dion type album that the winner has to mash out will be the comedy album of the year! And that would leave a singing talent like Emily to actually have a bit of time to record a decent album.

I think that might have been

I think that might have been the 'shock' to get Emily to the finish line - I bet she gets record levels of votes for the coming weeks.

It's time to go - James phew

It's time to go - James

phew

it's the ricki lee

it's the ricki lee factor...

this is the downfall of the voting system - voting for the best rather than the worst

Between James and Emily - I

Between James and Emily - I had a feeling it could be Emily - last night she was good but not her stunning self which might have made her fans a bit complacent.

puhlease lord let it be

puhlease lord let it be james...

My favourites are emily anne

My favourites are emily anne and lee. I don't like the daniels and kates ok. I want one of the daniels to go next.

I'M SOOO HAPPY EMILY WAS IN

I'M SOOO HAPPY EMILY WAS IN THE BOTTOM 3...

I'M SO ANGRY BECAUSE EMILY NEVER LEFT...

OH WELL SHE'LL LEAVE EITHER THIS WEEK OR THE FOLLOWING WEEK...

How awesome is this, I was

How awesome is this, I was doing my usual checking out Kate's new sites and she came on line, and I'm thinking what kind of question could I ask her cause she was just checking out the site...so I'm like- duh- thought I'd ask something really cheeky- and **dumb** um... (not intentional of course)

hey Kate, what song you going to sing for motown this Sunday?

and she replied-

ha ha cant tell you that you will have to wait and watch thursday night!!!

anyway im not really aloud to chat to much just to say thank you but remember that i do get on here as much as i can and i cant tell you how much i appreciate everything that you are all doing.

for me that was pretty cool...I know I'm being lame...but...

For those who love James,

For those who love James, I'd like you to consider these new voting options- spoken by the man himself on who should be crowned idol-

 "Here's the situation, I'd like to see Kate come first and Emily second. I think Emily's got the best chance without winning it, but both girls have got the goods in my eyes," James said.

lol

lol..i knew it! i knew you

lol..i knew it! i knew u were gonna say that!

~*luving James 4eva*~

lmao! omg..r you serious?

lmao! omg..r u serious?

hahaa..he is SERIOUSLY in luv with Kate

lol...I'm serious...lol

lol...I'm serious...lol

aww...that lucky girl lol

aww...that lucky girl lol

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Home