Get your American Idol Songs Here

LIVE VERDICT - 24 OCT 2005

Submitted by djwright on Mon, 2005-10-24 19:18

VOTING LINES NOW CLOSED...
Anne Robertson is now going home...

To tell you the truth, I’m a tad indifferent with tonight’s verdict only a few minutes away, I want Lee to go, it seems quite obvious that it’s his turn, but still his fanbase of stupid teenagers with no sense and even less logic than they have musical taste…

So, whatever happens tonight I’m not entirely fussed, but still, let’s see what happens anyway…

HAHAHAHAHAHA:
Tonight’s show started with The Hoff jumping on stage and welcoming everyone, after some running around and clapping of hands he introduced himself as both Andy and James and called for last night’s recap…

The entire world has gone Hoff crazy..

The Hoff kept on hosting the evening and started to introduce the judges before Andy G and James M were shown in the back screen tied up on a chair, as they broke out of the makeshift ropes Hoff yelled out “oh shit

EMILY ROX MY SOX!!!!!!! WHO

EMILY ROX MY SOX!!!!!!! WHO AGREEES!???????

I HEART EMILY 4EVA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I DON'T CARE WHAT ANYONE ELSE SAYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LEE IS ALSO VERY COOL BUT NOT AS COOL AS EMILY OR ANNE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I can't believe how bad Lee

I can't believe how bad Lee was this week. Obviously he is the choice of thousands of preteens around Australia. How embarrassing!

I've read all of your

I've read all of your comments and it's just to nice to see that you all agree with the fact that Lee shouldn't be in there. It does make me wonder though where all his votes come from..........preppy teenagers?  Awful.  and what on earth made him think he had the right to do one of Jacko's songs?

who the hell keeps voting

who the hell keeps voting for Lee?? Is Australia that seriously screwed up.

Anne was the 2nd best behinf Emily, but that counts for bugger all in the voting system.

Please get rid of Lee. He is worse than my underpants after red curry

-how many lives has Dan S

shite-how many lives has Dan S got!!!!!!!!  Roxy lost out to him, and he pretty much breaks James' record for being in the bottom three...I expected Lee to stay...although his song was totally c***...well everyone knows the answer to that one...

I was surprised Anne was in the bottom three- but I honestly thought the song choice just didn't work- I think that let her down majorly...and the problem is that Emily and Anne having similar styles- it's a matter of the one canceling the other out- if that makes any sense....similar thing happen in US idol between Latoya, Jennifer and Fantasia- the three divas...

I'll always maintain Kate offers that difference!!!!

It's interesting how Australia is voting- Dan E in the bottom 3 again- mmmmm- are Dan E and Dan S days numbered? 

Go Kate and Emily!!!!

I think Daniel did extra

I think Daniel did extra well, I agree that Anne's choice of song let her down, but she did not deserve to go as yet, Lee was by far the worse performer and should have been voted of, I just hope a real singer wins this. As far as Dan England being in the bottom three, he certainly did not deserve that, he and Daniel were the most improved last night, Emily is always striving and she is so full of confidence hard to stop her, but I really think Kate has the better voice.

it's getting so tight now-

it's getting so tight now- just depends so much on your fan base- if you've got the votes to get you across the line...

this is completely

this is completely f****d up seriously....what is australia thinking!!

far out....you people decide to get rid of one the most talented singers in the competition and sacrifice LEE HARDING....who cant even sing...i dont understand...

HES AN ENTERTAINER...blah blah...screw that....u need to sing aswell...far out...its a singin competition...

im just dumbfounded...

"YOU people"???Do you think

"YOU people"???

Do you think everyone here managed to deliberately keep Lee in the competition over Anne??? 

It's a competition.  Lee got more votes then Anne.  Who cares, Anne will still get a contract and have a song out within the next 12 months - that's when she'll really prove herself.  Who remembers out of the top 6 from the previous years where everyone but the top 2 came anyway?

No they didn't but my

No they didn't but my goodness, how he could still be there over so much better talent is a shame. He has personality and can be entertaining, but to see him up there trying to sing the idol song in front of millions of people is an emabarrassement. Stop the carnage Australia in vote with intelligence, this is a JOKE if he came into the final two, but I think he will last till 3 only.

yeh but it just bugs me that

yeh but it just bugs me that people leave when they give good performances...

PERFECT EXAMPLES: natalie, roxane and anne

SPOT ON...TOTALLY AGREE WITH

SPOT ON...

TOTALLY AGREE WITH YOU...

THEY GET RID OF THE SINGERS THAT SHOULD ALWAYS BE IN THE TOP 5... IF NOT TOP 3.

yepp lol....its bull

yepp lol....its bull crap...seriously...im sur u'd like to see roxane there over lee///

wouldnt you??

HELL YEAH!!

HELL YEAH!!

well....can you see what im

well....can u see what im trying to say?

Absolutely !!I understand

Absolutely !!

I understand like as if i were you writing it...

that anne, roxane and natalie should of stayed and that emily should of went...

lol...

no...not exactly....people

no...not exactly....

people like lee and dan england...

i like Dan E his awesome

i like Dan E his awesome

I totally agree with you. 

I totally agree with you.  I think he has a great voice and I hope he wins the competition.

id rather dan e over lee....

id rather dan e over lee....

Well ever since Roxy left...

Well ever since Roxy left...

Dan E has been my favourite...

And i don't know why everyone hates Lee and Dan...

Their really cool and deserve to stay...

there's only one person who doesn't deserve to stay...

and that is...

EMILY !!   SHE SUCKS... SHE CAN'T SING IF HER LIFE DEPENDED ON IT (well i think that was too harsh) BUT WHO CARES... SHE DOES SUCK... AND HAS TO LEAVE...

In Order Of Leaving :

E-M-I-L-Y TO GO

DANIEL S TO F-O-L-L-O-W

K-A-T-E IS REALLY GOOD... BUT HER FANS ARE JUST TOO HOLLOW

THAT THEN LEAVE'S LEE AND DAN, TO FIGHT IT OUT, MAN TO MAN...

WHO WILL WIN?? well i really haven't decided yet... but i hope Dan is named Australian Idol for the sake of all his fans...

YEAH... GO DAN !!!

Well, I don't live in Oz but

Well, I don't live in Oz but I've been keeping myself up-to-date with Australian Idol (with mp3's and videos) and I do have to say, Lee's performance of "Ben" was horrendous. A lot of people have been saying that Lee is the only thing that makes Aus Idol 3 interesting and that he can actually perform better than the others. But it's a singing competition - you have to be able to sing in the first place which, unfortunately, Lee can't! And that's a fact!!

However, with that said, the competition isn't about finding the best singer or who sung the best the evening before. It's about who's the most popular.

OMG. I am very angry that

OMG. I am very angry that Ann has left. It should have been Lee or Daniel Spillaine. I believe that Lee should have been voted off the show many weeks ago. He cannot sing intune and there is no career for him in the Australian Music Industry. Most of his fanbase is made up of lovestruck girls. Well I'm just here to tell you to get it through your head, he can't sing.

Yeah, this year was a farce

Yeah, this year was a farce from the moment you saw the top 30 anyway. I mean, that Jeremy joker was in the top 30 remember, and he is about as good (read that as crap) as Lee is. That angry Matt Damon looking dude was in the top30 and even got back on the wild card show.
I hate Marcia Hines' judging so much more than the other 2. Kyle and Mark might say some stupid things, but Marcia is an idiot. I mean, "well done Lee, you did a damn fine job". Wtf thing is that to say after what he just performed?

what else could they say? 

what else could they say?  Their wonder boy had shattered his image...

I expecting them to avoid the pitchy parts totally...lol...but it was just too plainly obvious...

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Home