Get your American Idol Songs Here

LIVE VERDICT - 14 November 2005

Submitted by djwright on Mon, 2005-11-14 16:32

HOW TO VOTE: Voting Lines ARE NOW CLOSED SO DON’T EVEN BOTHER!!!

Lets face it, there can only be three results from tonight’s verdict, and neither of them are particularly exciting…

Tonight we’ll find out who will be in the farce that will be the Idol series final, where last year’s American Idol showed two of the most spectacular vocal performances of the season this year’s final seems that it will be the same old same old. If Lee gets through then he’ll jump around like a epileptic tropical fish on acid, if Emily gets through then she’ll cry and then continue to be a few apples short of a pie and if Kate wins then Kyle’s going to make another comment about her washer woman arms and we’ll be delivered with a good but not great performance…

Join me from 7.30 for the verdict…

Here’s the three options:

Option 1.0

Option 2.0

Option 3.0

Idolblog Poll:

    This weeks poll results show that Emily is by far the most popular to go through this week while it is looking like this could be Kate’s last Hoorah, Lee is sitting in the second place, so who knows the punk prince might actually find himself “singing

hay im so GLAD that lee got

hay im so GLAD that lee got eliminated haha it duznt botha me hu really wins but i fink emily shuld win lolz huh how can ppl diss kate and emily cuz they r both really gud performers! dont u fink? wel i du ne waez. i fink its gana b a close vote between kate and emily lol IM SO HAPI LEE DIDNT GET TO THE FINAL CUZ HE DEZNT HAV THE LUKS, THE PERSONALITY OR THE VOICE TO MAKE IT IN THE MUSIK INDUSTRY LOL WHERE I FINK KATE AND EMILY HAS ALL DAT!

roxanelover: Out of

roxanelover: Out of interest, why do you always seem to type with your caps lock on?

I'm actually really glad that Lee didn't get through to the top 2.  He has done very well for himself getting as far as he has, and he has indeed been very different from what most of the others have brought to the show, but he just doesn't do it for me.  At all.  In fact, to put it mildly, I hated most everything he did.  But I can appreciate that he appealed to other people.

And honestly, while I like both Kate and Emily, I don't think either of them are really as good as I'd like to think our "Australian Idol" should be.  Both can sing really well, but for some reason both just don't seem to quite get there.  Maybe they can write good songs, I hope they can.  Maybe time and experience is what they need to truly become an "idol".  But for now they just fit in my mind as really good singers.

Looking forward to the show at the Opera House.  Hopefully it'll blow my socks off, cause none of the performances this year have done that for me yet.

I DON'T KNOW??? I GUESS

I DON'T KNOW??? I GUESS BECAUSE IT STANDS OUT!!!!!!-- refering to why i type in caps....

WELL.... I WANTED ROXY aka ROXANE TO GO THROUGH TO THE OPERA HOUSE WITH THE WIGGLE DUDE BUT DIDN'T TURN OUT THAT WAY....

FOR THE FINALE MY VOTE IS GOING TO KATE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

aww ...u poor thing! lol,

aww ...u poor thing! lol, emily's still in hahaa

well you did say that emily

well u did say that emily was ur fav....HAHA

NOOO....SHE SAID JAMES WAS

NOOO....

SHE SAID JAMES WAS HER FAV.

BUT LILMISS... REMEMBER.........

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

im talking when james

im talking when james left....she told me.....

emily is my favourite....

anyway who cares lol...she can go fro hu eva she wantss...

lol soz lilmiss...:D

lol..i was laughin at

lol..i was laughin at roxannelover..

but yea considering em and Kate..i go for Emily now :D

NOOOOOOOO....... GO

NOOOOOOOO....... GO KATE!!!!!!!!

SO.... WHO DO YOU WANT TO

SO.... WHO DO YOU WANT TO WIN........................................................

PLEASE KATE......... WHEN JAMES LEFT I THINK THAT WAS YOUR SECOND FAV.

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

Thanks for liked roxane, she

Thanks for liked roxane, she is one of my favorite as

well. i was so sad when she left the idol because she

such a great singer as well.

From point of view: The Top 5 should be:

Emily

Anne

Kate

Dan

Roxane

Why is everyone bagging out

Why is everyone bagging out Lee? Ok, so he doesnt have the greatest voice in the world, but dont you think hes gotten pretty far being compared to great voices like Kate and Emily? I think hes done exceptionally well, and quite frankly, im proud of him. GOOD ON YOU LEE!
I also agree with 'leeloverforlife'. I dont like Emily very much but you dont hear me going 'Oh shes so bad and stuff' so lay off him.

NOBODY FOR IDOL 2005

Look, stop being nutcases

Look, stop being nutcases about all this. Emily is the only one this year with serious ability. Let me sum it up for you, old school -

Emily - talented, raw
Kate - wedding singer, fat
Lee - High Five or pub bands. Ugly.
Dan E - elevator music, dirty
Dan S - high school performance, possibly gay
Anne - nightclub singer, saggy face
Laura G - shocking fringe, nice legs
Natalie - boring, fat
Roxane - Painful screeching
Tani - nasty, fat
Chris - talks like Tarzan, sings like Jane
That tazzie chick - can't sing, ugly
The other one - forgettable, who the hell was it anyway?

you forget Emily - few

you forget

Emily - few grapes short of a bottle of wine, pages short of a novel, bricks short of a house, oranges short of an orchard...

she's as thick as a brick.

I actually do feel for people like Chris, Roxanne and those who left in the first three weeks cause they're judged on one performance, where Anne and co at least got to sing a few times before being shown the arse.

If i were running the show I'd add 2 weeks to the show and allow for 2 weeks without voting at all before cranking on the competition.

Emily can sing, but when you call Tarni fat have you noticed how Emily's clothes hug her cellulite? When you say that Anne is a nightclub singer have you thought of paying $100 to see emily?

truth is this year they bombed because the show was handled badly, the wildcards were given to people that really didnt deserve it and forgot those who possibly could have improved...

f*** u!! ur a stupid ...who

f*** u!! ur a stupid cunt...who ever tha f*** u r!! LEE AND MILLY ARE MY FAVOURITES!!!!!!!! but do u hear me begging the other people out?? no!!!!! who do u think u r?? emily is a good singer, i agree. and thatz fine with u thinkin that, but u dont hav 2 make all those other mean and negative comments bout the onez u dont lyk as much jst 2 make u fell beta!!!!!!!!!!!! it's so pathetic!! even if u do think those things, keep them 2 urself!! GAY CUNT!!

If Lee and Milly are your

If Lee and Milly are your favourites then you've probably pulled off your ears and shoved them into your eyes, because it's less painful than having to look or listen to them

WHY DOES EVERYONE WANT KATE

WHY DOES EVERYONE WANT KATE TO WIN??????????

WHY DIDN'T YOU WANT DAN OR LEE........

BUT DON'T GET ME WRONG IT'S BETTER TO HAVE KATE THERE...

BECAUSE.......

EMILY IS STILL THERE AND KATE IS BETTER THAN HER AND SO KATE CAN WIN......

YESSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL!!!!!!!

i'v actually neva said i

i'v actually neva said i wanted Kate 2 win..i want JAMES TO WIN. -hmph-

but..good luck 2 Emily and Kate!! :D

the only people that want

the only people that want Kate to win live in bendigo - which will probably end up being a nuclear waste dumping ground

NO... THAT'S NOT TRUE...I'M

NO... THAT'S NOT TRUE...

I'M FROM SYDNEY.... AND I WANT KATE 2 WIN.......

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

You want kate to win just

You want kate to win just because you hate Emily... You are so fake, mate!

Emily has it won

Emily has it won Roxanelover. Just accept it.

Kate has as much chance of winning as a prison inmate has of using soap to clean themself with.

lmao.. ur suspiciously

lmao.. ur suspiciously reminding me of good old johnny boy :P *shifty eyes*

SHUT UP......... KATE HAS A

SHUT UP......... KATE HAS A CHANCE LOOK AT THE POLLS...

SHE'S NOW AT 42% AND THAT IS A REALLY GOOD CHANCE............

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

poles are only useful for

poles are only useful for girls to dance around

If you're not excited by

If you're not excited by this years final 3, then why bother writing these reviews?  Go and do something else if you don't like it. All seems a bit strange to me.

I'll tell you why, because

I'll tell you why, because the whole thing is unfair, that is why, people a miffed. Not just because their idol was voted of but clearly there are favoritism's in this comp; explain who could someone like Dan England be voted of in comparison the Lee and that Emily, really that is why we are still here.

I admit that Dan is good...

I admit that Dan is good... but certainly he doesn't have the whole package like Emily and Anne. He not confortable at all when he on the stage.... when he looked at the camera, his eyes keeped browsing around and can't just keep still toward camera. I think you can tell that especially his hand performance, everytime the same.... he will show up his hand from his chest several times in one song. He has a good vocal, but he needs more training in term of the performance on the stage

Dan got to top 4. That's

Dan got to top 4. That's either a pretty good effort for elevator music, or a reflection on how crap the others were. Probably both

I found it so hilarious that

I found it so hilarious that Emily was giving that spech. I just wanted Kate to go, "mate you havnt won yet, suck it in"

Im just relishing the fact Emily has NO votes on the poll!

I think it

I think it reasonable Emily was so hilarious. Because it is not easy to make that far. That's hilarious enough if got a chance to stand on the opera house stage, no need to talk win or lose. She's hilarious because she is from wildcard and could make this far, not because she think she won the idol. Wake up mate!

NOOOOOOO........ Lee

NOOOOOOO........ Lee left...

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS........... KATE GOT THROUGH.........   YES!!!!!!!!

She is ganna win.... i'll be posting comments EVERYWHERE!!!!!!

GO KATE.... Your go the best voice.... Your HOT !!!!!!....... Your AWESOME!!!!!!!!!

KATE I LOVE YOU............ ROCK ON KATE........ YOUR GANNA WIN AT THE GRAND FINAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS..........

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH..............

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005...........

DO YOU KNOW HOW GOOD THAT FEELS TO TYPE THAT GRACIOUS NAME IN???

IT'S AWESOME...............                GO KATE!!!!!!!

YOUR HOT....           AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH.........          SHE'S AWESOME............

SHE'S SOOOOOOOOO HOT................

GO KATE.....................

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

lol. you make me laugh..not

lol. u make me laugh..not sure y..either cos ur funny..in a good way or..i'm laughin at ur stupidity lol..

o well, take it as a compliment! ;)

lol lilmiss and

lol lilmiss and roxylover...ever since me n roxylover have became friends...ive been forced out of the talk...whats happening...lol i aint involved anymore...

maybe its because me studying...or maybe its because i said i wasnt gna fight wif you roxylover...well n e wayss...

GOO EMILYY:D.....GO KATEE:D

BUT EMILY MORE:D

oi stop just goin for

oi stop just goin for whoever isnt emily ay....  uve never sed anything good about akte before,,  n now just coz shes in the final ur all like "ohh shes hot, shes awum , she has the best voice".. damn ur pissen me off...
       EMILY FOR IDOL!!

WELLL....NOW THAT A FAV. OF

WELLL....

NOW THAT A FAV. OF MINE WENT I NEED SOMEONE WHO I ATLEAST CAN ENJOY THEIR PERFORMANCE AND EMILY DOESN'T DO IT FOR ME NEITHER DOES KATE BUT KATES BETTER......  SO I WANT HER TO WIN.....  AND SEEING THIS IS MY LAST CHANCE TO GET PEOPLE VOTING FOR KATE I HAVE TO DO SOMETHING!!!!!!!!!!

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

Mate, you got no attitute at

Mate, you got no attitute at all... you just don'y want Emily win then you saying how good Kate is... Please.... stand on your orginal point... DAN AND LEE, your favorite... they all gone now...

I like kate and emily.... so doesnt matter who win the idol. Anyway, the mission is almost complete now... because Emily kicked both Dan and Lee out..... LOL..............

EMILY AND KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

IS IT SUCH A CRIME FOR ME TO

IS IT SUCH A CRIME FOR ME TO NOT POST MY COMMENT....

AND WHO I THINK NOW IS GANNA WIN????

GOOOO KATE........ YOUR AWESOME.................

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

Thank you very much

Thank you very much Roxanelover, who ever you're supporting now, either kate or emily. They all my favorite, so i am happy you're supporting kate as well. This is 1st time we got the same opinion. Cheers mate. Hahahahahah.........

Well, every week Roxanlover

Well, every week Roxanlover says GO ****** FOR  AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005 and that's the person that gets voted off.

So Emily has it won

THAT'S LIKE THE FIRST

THAT'S LIKE THE FIRST TIME....

OK....... IF YOU CAN'T DECIDE ON WHO YOU THINK IS GANNA WIN THEN LETS MAKE IT EASIER...

WHO WOULD YOU WANT TO VOTE FOR  MORE???

lol haha your funny...GOO

lol haha your funny...

GOO EMILYY!!

GO KATE!!!!!! seriosuly if

GO KATE!!!!!!

seriosuly if my predictions are right about if Lee were to leave and then all his fans would want Kate to win because they don't want Emily to win then do you know how much i ought to be screaming......

THAT REALLY HAS A GOOD CHANCE OF HAPPENING...................................

THEY HAVE ENOUGH PEOPLE TO GET THE VOTES THROUGH... SO I DON'T SEE WHY IT WILL NOT HAPPEN.....

shut up wit ur predictions

shut up wit ur predictions hey.. lol.  they r never right!!!!!!
     and u dont no that all of lee's fans want kate to win!!!!

I DIDN'T SAY ALL OF

I DIDN'T SAY ALL OF LEE'S...

I SAID.......

MAJORITY!!!!!!

BELIEVE ME MAJORITY OF LEE'S FANS HAVE SOME WEIRD PROBKEM WITH ALL OF EMILY'S FANS.......... EXAMPLE:: Me..... i think it's because of the different style!!!!!!!

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

u did say all of lee's fans

u did say all of lee's fans btw ...."if my predictions are right about if Lee were to leave and then all his fans would want Kate to win"... and lee's fans arent guna hate emily coz of different styles.. did u watch idol on monday ... ther was a sign that sed            "EMI-LEE"...                   so thats a lee fan that liked emily... and theres probably more out there that arent like u!!!!

WELL YOU SHOULD KNOW WHAT I

WELL YOU SHOULD KNOW WHAT I MEAN....

AND IF YOU DON'T YOU HAVE A PROBLEM.............

i've got a problem. It's a

i've got a problem. It's a nagging itch in my underpants. Should I see a doctor?

I predict you should...

I predict you should... lmao........

KATE FOR AUSTRALIAN IDOL 2005

i've got a great line there

i've got a great line there Roxy, but since you're 13 and this is a family show, I'll keep it to myself..............

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Home